Proud Member Of

Rating the Lesbians, Volume 2
This time, it's personal...through angsty cunnilingus!
written by Emily & B on December 9, 2025

Volume 1 :: Volume 2 :: Volume 3 :: Volume 4 :: Volume 5 :: Volume 6 :: Volume 7

To recap:

Emily and I are friends. We like lesbians, but we hate bad movies, so we rate them like sardonic English majors. Michael Madsen shows up in this one. That woman deserves her revenge, and he deserves to die.

Enjoy!


Jessica Paré and Piper Perabo



Film: Lost and Delirious
(2001)
She: Lost.
She: Delirious; not able to fight the moonlight.

Emily: Okay, I'll admit, I really really dig this scene. Piper Perabo is famous for the movie "Coyote Ugly" and for looking like the anorexic Estella Warren. Jessica Paré is basically nobody, and she kind of looks like the indy film, French-Canadian version of Anne Hathaway. But they go balls-to-the-wall (only with an ironic lack of balls) in this scene. I think what really makes it strong is the fact that, unlike 90% of movies/films/video games/tv shows that feature any sort of lesbianism, this scene isn't some spur of the moment "now that we've found love what are we gonna do?" situations. The two characters are in love before we know them, before the film starts. And yes, it's superfluous. And yes, we don't really need to see explicit, full frontal sex between two girls who are supposed to be sixteen. But we live in a time when gay men are acceptable only as fashion mavens and raging stereotypes, and lesbians are a ratings stunt. So, I say, if that's how it's gonna be, bring on the cunnilingus. 'Cause, speaking as a mostly straight girl, that Paré chick has some of the nicest natural dubba dubba WB's I've ever seen.

B: The French-Canadian Anne Hathaway

What ruins this scene for me is the soundtrack. Normally your standard "bowwwww, wiggy wow wooooow" porno baseline sets up a solid foundation for masturbation. Instead the choice is "Beautiful" by Me' Shell Ndegéecello, which is basically:

"Oh girl, I like kissing you, you're so beautiful,
it sure is nice to kiss you, I enjoy kissing you,
kissing you is fun and you are beautiful
Oh yeah, beautiful kiss for you, beautiful kissy kissing"

And it goes on and on like that, so when the girls set up for the Finger Olympics you're left with a boner in your hand and the hidden track from Chris "Corky" Burke's first CD. Looking on the positive side, this is exactly what Coyote Ugly should've been. Nobody wants to pay up to ten bucks to sit and watch a movie about sexy girls being sexy when it's PG-13. It's like jacking off to the cover of Playboy. Piper Perabo should've been ass to ass with Tyra Banks while LeAnn Rimes sang an Indigo Girls song about not being able to buy fashionable Birkenstocks for the Moonlight. Also on the positive side, it's a lot nicer seeing Piper making out with Jessica Paré instead of seeing Piper make out with Sean O'Haire.

Overly Sarcastic I Love the 80s Personality says:
"Lost? No. Delirous? Yes. Absolutely. Delirious for this touching scene of love."

The P-Boi Sapphometer Reading: 4.5 Sappho


Monica Bellucci and Jada Pinkett Smith

Video Game: Enter the Matrix (2003)
She: Married to the Matrix version of Reneé Dupree, the Marovingian.
She: Married to the Matrix version of the Fresh Prince of Bel Air, Will 2K.

B: This is a step up from Bellucci's previous sexy roles because she isn't showing her George W to a bunch of twelve year olds. It's sad that they saved the lesbian scene for the video game. I'd love "Enter the Matrix" if it didn't look like Rockstar Games made it for the PSX. Video game manufacturers will never learn. We don't need to backflip off a wall and karate kick someone when the simple joy of planting a remote mine in "Goldeneye" and then exploding it in Oddjob's crotch exists on the N64. In "Smackdown: Here Comes the Pain" I can give Sable a spinning F5 from the top of a semi truck to the parking lot asphalt. What can I do in "Enter the Matrix," shoot at people with bullet time? Christ, in "The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past," which was made back in the long long ago I could try to pick up a heavy rock and make Link look like he was humping it.

The scene loses points for being too shadowy, and for Belluci being in her awful white "Reloaded" dress instead of her HOT WITH SEVENTEEN H'S red corset basketball holder from "Revolutions." Of all the robot girls on this list, Belluci is the one who gives me a Rodimus Prime. And that's the best transforming robot joke I've made since I sang "Boys of Summer" and changed the lyrics to:

"I thought I knew what love was,
What did I know?
Those days are gone forever...
I should just let 'em GOBOT"

PS: Jada is wearing dark sunglasses in the middle of a shadowy room. She better be careful or she'll end up kissing the dead masturbating guy in the convenience store bathroom.
PSS: Jason's Lyric: "Kee-hee-hee-ha-ha-ha."

Emily: B already pointed out the severe difference in hotness between Reloaded Bellucci and Revolutions Bellucci. And I liked Jada Pinkett-Smith better when her name was Spike Lee's Sister. So this scene (is it a scene when it's a video game?) had two minuses from the get go. Add in the fact that I've never actually played "Enter the Matrix" and that I am, in fact, talking about of my ass about two screen caps I just saw half a minute ago, and you wind up with one big, superfluous, half-assed lesbo scene.

Personally, my favorite lesbian video game moment was the touching scene of love between Princess Toadstool and a Goomba in Super Mario 3.

Overly Sarcastic I Love the 80s Personality says:
"No, I wouldn't care for a slice of orgasm cake, thank you. I'm already taken care of!"

The P-Boi Sapphometer Reading: 3.5 Sappho


Liv Tyler and Kate Hudson



Film: Dr. T and the Women
(2000)
She: THAT'S HER FATHER UP THERE
She: Getting pissed every time she says she "wants to go home" and somebody wiggles their fingers in her face and tells her that she IS home.

Emily: Okay, lemme review for you: Liv Tyler quits her record store job, then meets up with professional groupie Kate Hudson, and they *insert clever joke about "The Banger Sisters" here*. After a while, Kate is like, "hey little thing, lemme light your candle," and Liv is all, "walk this way" so they give each other a little three second kiss to signify that they're lesbians, and then Richard Gere dies. Oops gave away the ending.

I really feel that Dr. T and the Women would've been twice the movie it is if Dr. T just hadn't had that Ph D.

. . . think about that for a minute, you'll get it. I made a funny joke, I swear.

B: I have these elaborate fantasies worked out in my head where two gorgeous celebrities do nasty things to each other, and it vindicates the part of me that decided long ago that I'd never be playing the gay friend on Dawson's Creek. What it more specifically does is prime me for the disappointment of watching two women who clearly aren't into it force themselves to kiss for a movie. I would've killed to see Crazy-video gay schoolgirl Liv making out with Penny Lane. Hell, I still would. But this is Dominatrix-punishing-Paul-Reiser one night at McCool's Liv Tyler and OUR LOVE FERN YOU LET IT DIIIIIE Kate Hudson. By this point Liv is way less attractive than her sister Mia, and Kate Hudson is so annoying that I've decided I'd rather pitch for Oliver. So I end up fantasizing about Mia Tyler and Oliver Hudson making out and am surprised by my buoyant heterosexuality and have to take a nap. A nap with FOOTBAAAAAALLLLLL

Overly Sarcastic I Love the 80s Personality says:
"Personally I prefer 'Mr. T and the Women.' 'I pity the fool who isn't a gynecologist for some of the wealthiest women in Texas! Stop your jibber-jabber!' Hey, remember Rubix Cube?"

The P-Boi Sapphometer Reading: 1 Sappho


Mia Kirshner and Kim Murphy

Television Show: 24, (Season 1)
She: Mandy the Lesbian Terrorist.
She: Bridget the Midget Other Lesbian Terrorist.

B: Part of the complex plan to assassinate President(ial candidate) Pedro Cerrano is for Mia Kirshner, the bitchiest girl in school, to get the security pass for a lookalike killer to use before she can turn it over to the terrorists. Her girlfriend convinces her to double the asking price, so they passionately kiss. Later, Mandy invites the new President to "talk to the palm" and Bridget is shot by Ira Gaines for fucking up the deal. Getting shot is one of two ways a 24 character can end up. The other is "working for CTU." By season 4 the fucking ominous cougar will be working the boards with Chloe.

Can I ask you a question? Why is it then whenever Mandy the Lesbian Terrorist tell a guy to put it wherever they want, they always stick it in her ass?

PS: Mia Kirshner has also made out with "Lolita's" Dominique Swain and others in "New Best Friend" and with an old lady in "Not Another Teen Movie." She's also the star of a new TV series "The L Word." I don't know which side she butters her bread on, but it can be assumed that she sticks those talking Parkay containers in her vagina.
PSS: Somebody should make a TV series called "The N Word" and have it be about white nurses.
PSSS: 24 is the best show ever.

Emily: The one thing that alienates me from every other person on this website is the fact that I've never watched a single episode of 24 in my life. I wanted to, but sadly I haven't gotten around to viewing the previous 23 yet. But, for a Smudge knock-off, that Kirshner chick ain't too shabby. And since 24 is apparently the Alpha of television shows, I've got to assume even their pointless lesbian storylines would be more entertaining than other venues of pointless lesbianism. Unless it involved Spawn of Keifer. Then not so much. Unless Spawn of Keifer got it on with that cougar everyone keeps talking about. That'd be cool. Unless the cougar turned out to be Johnny Cougar, then it wouldn't even be a lesbian scene.


. . . and I'm spent.

Overly Sarcastic I Love the 80s Personality says:
"Tell you who I work for? Why VH1, of course! No need for violence. What the world needs now is love. Sweet love."

The P-Boi Sapphometer Reading: 2 Sappho


Naomi Watts and Laura Harring

Film: Mulholland Dr. (2001)
She: Before she dies, she sees The Ring. Like Owen Hart.
She: Two-time Slammy Award Winner. Like Owen Hart. Wait.

Emily: For two years I attended a small, private women's college hidden away in central Virginia. Unlike larger colleges, which tend to offer free second run screenings of your typical multiplex fare, the head of our film department went out of her way to bring in smaller films, things that we otherwise wouldn't be able to see living in the country just south of Lynchburg, Virginia. So when it was announced that that the school would be showing Mullholland Drive, I was excited. The film was getting strong reviews, though all anyone seemed to focus on was the extended girl-on-girl love scenes that made up most of the film's last 45 minutes.

So, I invited B to the screening, convinced my three roommates to come along as well, and off we went. After the first hour and a half, the highlight of which was Billy Ray Cyrus' brief cameo, the natives got a little restless. B began alternating between sighing audibly and putting his head down on chair in front of him. And my roommates all started to turn and look at me with the expression of a five year old who doesn't want to sit and listen to Weird Uncle Larry's stories anymore. So I gave up. We all left the screening, and all the girl sex I was so curious to see eluded me.

I finally got to see "good parts," if only in clip form. And, admittedly, had I made it through the film the first time, I probably would've switched teams right there at the screening. I did go to a girls school after all. But yeah, well done stuff. However, its hard for me to get behind anything with Naomi Watts, having seen her various appearances in films and on the posters for said films in the last three years. Seriously, stare at the big cardboard stand up for Le Divorce in your local theater long enough, it'd turn you into a eunich. She always looks to be trying out Smell-the-fart acting. Bah.

B: So Laura Herring is a program, correct? Oh wait, has she actually been dead this whole time? Oh I don't know =(

Naomi Watts also had some Finger Hooked on Lesbionics with Lori Petty in "Tank Girl," which contains a gangster rapper as an anthropomorphic wallaby and STILL makes more sense than Mulholland Dr.. I don't care what any film major tells me, changing characters in the middle of a movie isn't "clever" or "creative." It's just a cop-out, especially when David Lynch KEEPS DOING IT. Is his twin brother finishing his scripts for him? At least Lynch's next movie, "The 3," is supposed to be psychologically taut.

I just referenced "Adaptation." Isn't that fucked up?

Overly Sarcastic I Love the 80s Personality says:
"Doesn't make sense? Surely you jest. I'm going to Mulholland DRIVE to my theater and see it!"

The P-Boi Sapphometer Reading: Yeah, okay, 5 Sappho.


Denise Richards and Neve Campbell

Film: Wild Things (1998)
She: A 30 year old pretending ot be 20; recently married Charlie Sheen and infected with the Joker's venom.
She: A 30 year old pretending to be 20; watching the Scream movies by herself in the dark.

B: Easily the most overrated scene in movie history. First of all, look at that picture of Denise Richards with her shirt off. Look at her torso. Personal preferences aside, you can't look at that and tell me it isn't gross. She looks like a bag of snakes. Like somebody laminated an Ethiopian. Her implants just hang from her body, and she's got that huge head and smile, and I fear that her head is going to split open and the Violator is going to pop out. Secondly, this is one of many Neve Campbell "nude scenes" where she takes off her shirt and all we see is her kissing somebody with her back to the camera. Gee, that's really sexy Neve, let me ejaculate to the site of your spine before Trinity sucks it out of your navel. Thirdly, it's MATT DILLON pushing them together, and groaning and making "oh yeah" sound effects as he drinks from Denise's chest crevices. Matt Dillon makes me want to vomit into ice trays and then hurl chunks of my hardened sick at his face.

For a more hilarious group sex scene watch "The Contender," where Joan Allen gets fingercuffed by a couple of hippies. For a sexier scene watch any other movie ever made. Watch "Dead Alive." A zombie catching a lawnmower to the forehead is more entertaining than watching Denise Richards seductively wash a car.

Emily: I've never understood the the appeal of Neve Campbell. She's so squinty and cry-face all the time. Plus, in every movie she does she manages to work in that *heavy sigh+whimper+hiccup* combo she perfected in the "Scream" films as a way to express sadness/fright/grief/orgasmic delight. That being said, I think this scene, plastic boobs and all, would've been completely redeemed if Matt Dillon had been replaced by Pony Boy Curtis.

Overly Sarcastic I Love the 80s Personality says:
"Excuse me, GARCON? I'd like a bottle of the Vintner's Reserve and perhaps a sample of Denise Richards' bosom."

The P-Boi Sapphometer Reading: 2 Sappho


Calista Flockhart and Lucy Liu



Television Show: Ally McBeal
(searchin' her soul tonight)
She: she she she oh looking for, uh, love oh and she she she, uh, is nervous all the time about, about, about being a lawyer, you knooooow, and and and her biological clock is, is ticking, and oh, she she, oh (gets hit in the face with a hilariously oversized suction cup arrow)
She: The fourth crime-fighting posession of Beyonce Knowles, along with my girl Drew, Cam-Ron Di and Destiny.

Emily: I remember watching this when it was on TV. The two women spent like five minutes leaning in towards each other, Calista bugged her eyes out a little to show she was emoting, then they kissed, while barely opening their mouths. And there was probably a rockin' Vonda Shepard song on the soundtrack. This scene fell right in the heyday of "must see girl-kiss tv," right around the same time Rachel was making out with Winona, and those two 14 year olds were gettin' freaky on that show about Sela Ward doing the Rocketeer. But, and I've said this before, if you're going to convince two women to pretend they want to make out, and you're doing it soley for the brief ratings hike, at least make the ACTRESSES to ACT like they have any interest in being there. Otherwise, just show us more of that god damned dancing baby. God, Ally McBeal sucked.

B:
As your leader, I encourage you from time to time, and always in a respectful manner, to question my logic. If you're unconvinced that a particular plan of action I've decided is the wisest, tell me so, but allow me to convince you and I promise you right here and now, no subject will ever be taboo. Except, of course, the subject that was just under discussion. The price you pay for bringing up either my pre-fame stripper movies ("City of Industry") or my post-fame trite crap-train (Charlies Angels, Ally McBeal, Ballistic: Ecks vs. Sever) as a negative is - I collect your fucking head. Just like this eight pound fucker here. Now, if any of you sons of bitches got anything else to say, now's the fucking time!

Overly Sarcastic I Love the 80s Personality says:
"Black Mamba. I shoulda been motherfuckin' Black Mamba. Wait no I mean remember Saved by the Bell?"

The P-Boi Sapphometer Reading: 3 Deadly Uma


Kate Winslet and Melanie Lynsky

Film: Heavenly Creatures (1994)
She: Would rather be his whore than your wife.
She: ABSOLUTELY BONKERS!

B: My thoughts on Kate Winslet are extensive. I think she's one of the most beautiful women on the planet, and I like about half of her movies, which is better than I can say for even my favorite actresses. See Birch, Thora: "Dungeons and Dragons," "Now and Then," "Hocus Pocus." See also Johansson, Scarlett: "The Horse Whisperer," "Eight Legged Freaks," "Home Alone 3." This happens to be one of two films where she's had a lesbian scene, and if you get them confused here is an easy pamphlet to explain:

1) Heavenly Creatures - directed by Peter Jackson so it's easy to pretend that one of the girls is Legolas (omg swoon); features girls having sex with statues. Then with/actually with each other.
2) Holy Smoke! - the one where she pees on herself.

This is one of many films my friend Cristy made me watch because it had lesbians in it. I didn't have a problem with the lesbians. What I had a problem with was Melanie Lynsky's voice. She seriously sounds like me doing a Crocodile Dundee impression. Every time I'd attempt to take the movie seriously she'd saunter in with a:

"
We realised why Deborah and I have such extraordinary telepathy and why people treat us and look at us the way they do. It is because we are MAD. We are both stark raving MAD!"

Who is she, the dead Old Navy lady? Do an impression of Steve Irwin sticking his thumb in a snake's butt as you read that and you've got Melanie Lynsky. The actual scene is pretty entertaining, but Kate Winslet isn't a great screen kisser unless she's pissing off Emma Thompson by driving her tongue down Kenneth Branaugh's throat in "Hamlet."

Emily: Hey,
farkers, check this out: Kate Winslet?! *fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap* Ugh Ugh Ugh SHAZAAAAAM! *cue dead kittens*
I dunno about you man, but I'm turned on by Winslets tendency to have sex with inanimate objects/be an inanimate object and get sexed by Joaquin Phoenix. For that matter, I'd probably be turned on if she were having sex with Steve Irwin. Or the crocodile. Or even that Jeff Corwin fucker.

Overly Sarcastic I Love the 80s Personality says:
"Lesbians? More like thespians!"

The P-Boi Sapphometer Reading: 3 Sappho


Larisa Oleynik and Katherine Heigl

Film: 100 Girls (2000)
She: Not able to date until somebody falls in love with her sister, Julia Stiles. So she's either moving to Harlem or waiting for a loooong time.
She: Pretending to date her father, the hero; alien.

Emily: I'm not gonna lie, I've never seen this movie. I think at one point I saw the last ten minutes, which I spent staring at the screen with my head cocked to one side making exaggerated Home Improvement "AROOO?" noises. So, we're going to assume that "100 Girls" sucks. That being said, I once upon a time harbored quite the crush on Katherine Heigl. Actually, I could never figure out if I had a real crush on her, or one of those girl-crushes that stems from just being in complete awe/envy of another woman's body. I just know when she was on Roswell she seemed like an Amazon, this huge girl with giant perfect boobs and a sour expression. Then I saw that MTV version of "Wuthering Heights" that featured Swimfan Erika Christensen fucking the lead singer from the Ataris, and Heigl was there, looking like a complete crackwhore. I died a little that day.

Anyway, in this scene, Heigl appears to re-enact the famous Lady and the Tramp spaghetti scene with Larissa Oleynik, funny hat enthusiast and professional dater of Joseph Gordon-Levitt. I'm really torn here. On the one hand, I think that last Lady and the Tramp re-enactment that I can remember was Hot Shots: Part Deux. I'm not sure if that makes it tacky, or cute by reason of nostalgia. I'm leaning towards the latter. But, on the downside, Larisa has Tiny Bangs. Boo that.

So, in conclusion, Heigl will probably be in Skinamax double-donging it in like two years. Don't go out of your way to watch this.

B: I know they said "Secret World of Alex Mack," but this is ridiculous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!

!!

1

Larisa Oleynik is like the farm team for a girl I'd want to fuck. I may remember Katherine Heigl from such television commercials as the advertisement for "My Father the Hero," where she alarms Gérard Depardieu and sends fourteen year old me into tongue-down business-up by being her and wearing a thong. When people talk about bad movies they mention Showgirls or Gigli or whatever Oliver Platt is doing now, but "My Father the Hero" deserves more condemnation. It not only revolves around a girl trying to impress a boy she's just met by pretending that her father is having sex with her, but features the Baha Men, artisans behind "Who Let the Dogs Out?" half a decade before their reign of hellfire. I was also disappointed with the inclusion of French people who do not attack Americans with the French flag when their back is turned.

"100 Girls" is only better than one film: "100 Women," the same movie remade with girls maybe two years older by the same director. To tell you the kind of quality we're working with, Heigl is ACTUALLY CREDITED as "Arlene, the Competitive Tomboy" and Oleynik is credited as "Wendy, the Girl Next Door." He should've named his protagonist "Joe Everyman." They kiss, kinda, and Michael Davis is forgiven yet again, in the same vein that he was forgiven for "Eight Days a Week" when he got full=haired Keri Russell naked. You're a slippery cad, Michael Davis! I bet he checks into hotels as "Michael, the Shitty Writer."

Overly Sarcastic I Love the 80s Personality says:
"I have lost the ability to feel legitimate nostalgia for anything. What's that on your shirt? (flicks your nose) Haha! Remember Shrinky Dinks?"

The P-Boi Sapphometer Reading: Pre-Crisis Katherine Heigl rates 3 on the Sapphometer


Gina Gershon and Jennifer Tilly



Film: Bound
(1996)
She: Playing "Corky" in the film "Bound."
She: Assumedly playing "Becca" in the film "Bound."

B: You're BOUND to love this scene! But I almost GAGGED! Ho ho. I'm the best writer ever.

I've got nothing against these women. I think they're fine human beings who have a lot to offer in their families and circle of friends. But regardless of how many fingers are going into how many orifices I, as a twenty-three year old, just can't get into two forty-year old women "gettin it on" Lesbian UFC-style. I'm sorry. I know I'm in the complete minority here. This is generally considered one of if not the best sex scene of all-time, but as Emily once said about Willow and Kennedy on Buffy, you can't get O-face from your finger. Maybe you can, but if I'm to buy Gina Gershon as a butch lesbian I'm going to need more than Jennifer Tilly's finger and boob hanging there. And when they kiss it looks less like kissing and more like two jungle lizards flapping their tongues in each others mouths.

Wait, whoa, I just figured out the Matrix. So it's a MACHINE WORLD?

Huh.

Are the Bound girls in the Matrix? I guess lesbians need love...like everything else does. So let me say something positive about this. Gershon's character's name is "Corky." That's hilarious. And ironic, because she so infrequently gets corked!

Emily: As stated in the previous volume of Rating the Lesbians, Gina Gershon is hot. Also, this movie is high on the Gia scale. That is to say, its probably in the top five films that have caused overweight manic depressives on the internet to declare themselves "bi-sexual." You're not bi-sexual, dipshit, you're just alone. Log back on and spare me the defense of "Donnie Darko." So basically, I like this scene itself, but I hate that this movie has become appropriated by chicks who would read "Strangers in Paradise."

On an only slightly related note, the Tilly/Gershon scene is one of many sex scenes that's been downloaded and viewed on B's computer. Along with the Paris Hilton sex tape. And Low Ki vs. Amazing Red. Of the three, the Red match gave B the biggest erection.

Overly Sarcastic I Love the 80s Personality says:
"I am on a show about a bowling lawyer."

The P-Boi Sapphometer Reading: 4 Sappho, with a B-rating of 2 Sappho
+

AGREE? DISAGREE? LESBEE? AN? Tell us about it in the P-Boi Forums!

Volume 1 :: Volume 2 :: Volume 3 :: Volume 4 :: Volume 5 :: Volume 6 :: Volume 7

B

 

emily

b @ progressiveboink.com
AIM: destinys2ndkid
B's Archives

emily @ progressiveboink.com
AIM: Roxymoron87
Emily's Archives

Main Archives