When a band's best song is not on their best album

[beggar]

Piebald
Best song: Just a Simple Plan
Best album: All Ears, All Eyes, All the Time

write in vote for Grace Kelly With Wings


Boris
Best song: Naki Kyoku
Best album: Pink

[Justin]

Damn son now you've got me all re-evaluating my decision and shit.

[Z.S. Ghost]

The Kinks
Best Song: "Lola" or "You Really Got Me". Yeah, I am totally confusing "popular" and "best".
Best Album: The Kinks Are The Village Green Preservation Society.

[Casey]

I hate "You Really Got Me" so much

[Duzzy Funlop]

waterloo sunset is the answer here

[Z.S. Ghost]

Whatever you say! Still not on Village Green.

[webber]

All Day And All Of The Night

[Z.S. Ghost]

Fine! Fine, that's the best song by the Kinks. It's still not on Village Green, so it fits.

[Maynard,]

I would say that Lola vs. Powerman and the Moneygoround Part One is as good as Is The Village Green Preservation Society, but it also does not have Waterloo Sunset.

[First-Tiger]

Sufjan Stevens
Best song: Either "The Mistress Witch from McClure (or, The Mind That Knows Itself)" or "For the Widows in Paradise, For the Fatherless in Ypsilanti"
Best album: Illinois

Destroyer
Best song: Notorious Lightning
Best album: Destroyer's Rubies

[B]

Sufjan Stevens
Best song: Either "The Mistress Witch from McClure (or, The Mind That Knows Itself)" or "For the Widows in Paradise, For the Fatherless in Ypsilanti"

Sufjan and the guy from Panic at the Disco should write a song together and call it the entirety of Great Expectations.

[Maynard,]

That is essentially daring Wayne Coyne to use The Tale Of Genji as a song title.

[blacktoothgrin]

Metallica

Best Song "One"
Best Album "Ride The Lightning"

[Hanstock]

God, NO.

Metallica
Best Song: "Fade To Black"
Best Album: Master of Puppets

[Randy Jones]

metallica

best song: n/a
best album: n/a

j/k best album is that black one and the best song is probably offa that too ps metallica sucks

[blacktoothgrin]

God, NO.

Metallica
Best Song: "Fade To Black"
Best Album: Master of Puppets

Psh. Fade To Black's lyrics are trash. Also a band's best song should be the one that showcases everything about that band. One does that, Fade To Black does not.

[Wez]

Their best song is what I say their best song is.

[Dollo]

Metallica
Best Song: For Whom The Bell Tolls
Best Album: Black

[Wez]

Metallica would be a more interesting album poll than RHCP I think. Black would probably win, but it is not the best.

[Dollo]

Well, then hop-to and create the thread son.

Curiously, are you gonna include "Metallica S&M"? I know it's a compilation album kinda, but hot damn was it good.